9 Movies That Feel Like A24 But Aren't

A24MOVIES

2 min read

Introduction

Religion on television usually falls into neat, reverent boxes—or avoids the topic altogether. But these nine shows boldly step into the gray areas, challenging dogma, exploring faith in crisis, and diving into the human need for belief. Whether it’s through horror, satire, sci-fi, or raw drama, each series presents a unique and often unsettling lens on organized religion, spirituality, and the divine. If you’re drawn to stories that wrestle with big questions and aren't afraid to blur the sacred with the profane, these shows are a must.

1. The Substance

This indie gem captures the same offbeat energy and surreal, introspective storytelling that A24 is known for. With its eerie, dreamlike quality and exploration of identity, it feels like a deep dive into psychological unraveling. The haunting visuals and off-kilter tone make it an instant fit for fans of the A24 catalog.

2. Nocturnal Animals

Dark, stylish, and psychologically complex, Nocturnal Animals exudes the same unsettling, melancholic energy that defines many A24 films. With its haunting narrative structure and themes of regret, revenge, and broken relationships, it’s a film that plays with your mind long after it’s over, much like an A24 thriller would.

3. Get Out

Jordan Peele’s Get Out is a masterclass in tension and subtext. Its sharp social commentary and slow-burn horror echo the cerebral intensity that A24 often delivers. Blending race, psychological horror, and genre filmmaking, it’s a film that makes you think, feel, and be on edge—qualities that A24 films excel at.

4. Longlegs

With its atmospheric dread, surrealism, and dark exploration of human relationships, Longlegs offers the same strange, thought-provoking vibe as many A24 films. Its themes of obsession and isolation are handled with a delicate but disturbing touch, giving it an edge that would be right at home in an A24 lineup.

5. I’m Thinking of Ending Things

Charlie Kaufman’s I’m Thinking of Ending Things feels like it could’ve been a cornerstone in the A24 catalog. Its cerebral narrative and exploration of existential despair perfectly align with the studio’s signature psychological explorations. The eerie atmosphere, complex character dynamics, and fragmented storytelling make this one feel deeply A24-esque.

6. Pig

Nicolas Cage delivers one of his best performances in this understated, emotionally resonant story, a quality often associated with A24. With its slow, deliberate pacing and focus on grief and redemption, Pig offers a raw, beautifully melancholic exploration of loss and human connection, making it a spiritual cousin to the A24 catalog.

7. Mother!

Darren Aronofsky’s Mother! is a feverish, intense film, deeply unsettling and relentless in its exploration of creation, destruction, and human nature. The film’s surreal, allegorical style, along with its tension-filled atmosphere, makes it a film that could easily slot into the A24 repertoire, with its heady blend of horror and existential reflection.

8. Ingrid Goes West

This dark comedy about obsession and social media feels like something A24 could’ve picked up, thanks to its off-kilter tone and exploration of the darker side of human nature. Aubrey Plaza’s performance as a deeply flawed, lonely woman trying to fit in with the "cool crowd" echoes the types of character studies A24 thrives on, blending discomfort with dark humor.

9. It Follows

A film that expertly blends supernatural horror with themes of sexual anxiety and the passage of time, It Follows feels like it could’ve been birthed by A24, thanks to its atmospheric dread and genre-defying premise. It’s subtle, yet profoundly disturbing, and like many A24 films, it leaves a lingering sense of unease, making it a must-watch for those seeking that A24 vibe.