DCU Batman Fancast: Who Should Don the Cowl Next?

DCU Batman Fancast: Who Should Don the Cowl Next?

With the DCU gearing up for a full reboot under James Gunn, one of the most anticipated castings is none other than Batman. The Dark Knight has been reimagined countless times on screen, from Michael Keaton’s gothic detective to Christian Bale’s grounded vigilante and Robert Pattinson’s moody, noir-driven take. But with a new era of DC storytelling ahead, fans are wondering who will wear the cape and cowl next. In this fancast, we explore some of the strongest contenders—actors who could bring the perfect balance of grit, intelligence, and humanity to Gotham’s protector.

Alan Ritchson is a powerhouse when it comes to physical presence and action. He can truly embody the imposing, intimidating aspects of Batman that make him such a force in Gotham. His role in Reacher almost served as a live audition for the Dark Knight, showcasing both his size and combat skills. Plus, Ritchson isn’t new to DC—his role in Titans gives him experience in the superhero world. If the next Batman needs to be both physically commanding and capable of intense action sequences, he’s a perfect fit.

Alan Ritchson

Wilson Bethel brings the perfect mix of cerebral intelligence and brooding intensity. He can channel the sophisticated Bruce Wayne persona while also diving deep into Batman’s darker, more calculating side. Much like David Cornsweat, he’s a lesser-known actor, which means he could make the role entirely his own. His performance in Daredevil as Bullseye proved he can handle morally complex, high-stakes roles—qualities that would translate seamlessly to Gotham’s protector.

Wilson Bethel

Jensen Ackles is likely many fans’ top pick, and for good reason. He has the charm, charisma, and suave presence that makes Bruce Wayne believable as Gotham’s billionaire playboy. At the same time, he captures Batman’s duality—the stoic, driven vigilante behind the mask. His role as Soldier Boy in The Boys proves he can handle superhero action while maintaining layered, nuanced performances, making him a compelling candidate for the role.

Jensen Ackles

Jake Gyllenhaal is arguably the strongest actor on this list. While he’s already appeared in a superhero movie as Mysterio, his range and skill would make him a fantastic Batman. He has the physique, presence, and intensity needed for interrogation-heavy scenes, making moments like a tense “Swear to me!” feel electric. Gyllenhaal’s ability to balance charm, menace, and vulnerability would make him a dynamic Dark Knight.

Jake Gyllenhaal

Theo James is my personal top pick. He combines charisma, swag, and acting chops in a way that could make both Bruce Wayne and Batman equally compelling. Though most of his previous hits were in YA adaptations, he has the potential to own this character fully. Pairing him with David Cornsweat’s Superman would create a striking dynamic, and this could easily be the film that propels him into superstardom while redefining Gotham’s vigilante for a new generation.

Theo James