Heretic: Faith, Fear, and Hugh Grant at His Chilling Best

Hugh Grant delivers a masterclass performance as Mr. Reed, a character who embodies complexity and intrigue. With a blend of chilling menace, sharp intimidation, and subtle charm, Grant proves why he’s the perfect choice for such a compelling antagonist. He expertly balances the darker elements of his character with an unsettling charisma, making Mr. Reed both terrifying and magnetic. Grant’s performance stands as the backbone of the film, anchoring the story with his commanding presence.

Sophie Thatcher and Chloe East also deliver exceptional performances as the LDS missionaries, capturing the vulnerability and inner conflict of their characters. Both actors convey fear, doubt, and confusion in their religious discussions with Mr. Reed, infusing these moments with an intensity that keeps viewers on edge. The conversations between them and Mr. Reed are both gripping and thought-provoking, revealing not only their personal struggles but also the broader themes the film seeks to explore.

True to A24’s signature style, Heretic builds quietly, taking its time to develop tension and atmosphere before shifting into the unexpected. The pacing is deliberate, allowing the dread to slowly seep in and build as the story progresses. This slow-burn approach keeps the audience invested, even as the film edges into more surreal and unsettling territory. The balance between suspense and horror is expertly maintained, making every scene feel fraught with significance.

Despite some flaws in the third act, Heretic ultimately succeeds in weaving a chilling religious allegory with elements of horror. The film explores themes of faith, belief systems, and the profound impact that religious ideologies can have on individuals. While the finale may feel somewhat rushed or uneven, the emotional and thematic weight of the preceding acts more than makes up for it. Heretic offers a thought-provoking take on the intersection of faith and fear, and its haunting depiction of belief systems leaves a lasting impact.

In the end, Heretic is a film that lingers in your mind long after it’s over, with standout performances and a gripping atmosphere that make it a standout piece of horror cinema. The performances, particularly Grant’s portrayal of Mr. Reed, elevate the film beyond its genre conventions, making it a thought-provoking and chilling experience.