The Holdovers: A Modern Holiday Classic You Won't Want to Miss

The Holdovers is a surprise contender for one of my favorite films of the year, effortlessly blending heartwarming storytelling with exceptional performances. Directed by Alexander Payne, the film harks back to a more classical style of filmmaking, using simplicity and emotional depth to its advantage. At its center is Paul Hunham, played to perfection by Paul Giamatti. Giamatti brings warmth, wit, and an undercurrent of melancholy to a role that could have easily veered into curmudgeonly cliché. Instead, he crafts a deeply human character who becomes increasingly compelling as the film progresses.

The heart of The Holdovers lies in the unexpected bond between Paul and Angus, a rebellious student played by Dominic Sessa in a fantastic breakout performance. The chemistry between Giamatti and Sessa is undeniable, and their evolving relationship gives the film much of its emotional weight. Their dynamic is filled with conflict, humor, and eventually, genuine affection, making their arc incredibly satisfying to watch unfold.

Da’Vine Joy Randolph is equally phenomenal as Mary Lamb, the school’s grieving cook. Her performance adds layers of sorrow and tenderness that quietly ground the film’s themes of loss, loneliness, and redemption. Together, the trio becomes an unlikely surrogate family, and it’s their shared sense of isolation—and their gradual connection—that gives The Holdovers its timeless quality.

Set against the cold backdrop of a 1970s New England winter, the setting itself becomes a character. Snowy landscapes, muted tones, and old-school decor enhance the film’s nostalgic atmosphere, capturing the stillness and sadness of a Christmas spent far from home. The aesthetic feels authentically retro, not in a gimmicky way, but as a natural extension of the film’s tone and themes.

What makes The Holdovers so memorable is its balance—it’s funny without being cynical, sentimental without being saccharine. The story may be modest in scope, but its emotional resonance is lasting. The film takes its time, allowing its characters to breathe and its quieter moments to land with impact.

Ultimately, The Holdovers is a soulful and satisfying watch that feels destined to become a holiday staple. It’s a film about grief, growth, and human connection told with tenderness and sincerity. If you’re looking for something heartfelt and timeless this holiday season, The Holdovers is not to be missed.